Skip to content
SearchSphereSource
Sign inSign up

The E-Myth Revisited (Michael E. Gerber) vs The Outsiders (Will Thorndike)

Side by Side

The E-Myth Revisited (Michael E. Gerber) and The Outsiders (Will Thorndike), attribute by attribute
AttributeThe E-Myth RevisitedThe Outsiders
What It IsThe argument that most small businesses are built by someone good at the work rather than by someone building a company, so the owner ends up inside the job instead of above it. The fix it proposes is documented systems and defined roles, so the business can run to a standard without the person who started it. For a buyer that is a description of the company being bought, written from the seller's side.The 2012 Harvard Business Review Press book that measures eight chief executives on a single thing, the long-run return to their shareholders, and finds that what they shared was capital allocation: what each did with the cash the business produced, including buying back their own shares when nothing better was on offer. The publisher's page states the thesis in those terms and carries endorsements from Warren Buffett, Charlie Munger and Michael Dell.
CategoryBooksBooks
Pricing ModelOne-TimeOne-Time
What It CostsA book, sold in every format. The author's own site carries the series and no price on the pages read, so the figure depends on edition and retailer rather than on anything published at source.$32.00 from the publisher (store.hbr.org, read August 2026), whose own page also tells a buyer to see the retailer for the price; sold in every format at standard retail. Published October 23, 2012.
Best ForUnderstanding the owner-dependence you are about to inherit, before you inherit itThe buyer who has closed, or is about to, and now has to decide what the business does with the cash it throws off. It is not a how-to for buying and it teaches neither search nor diligence.
Where It FitsOperate & Grow the BusinessDefine & Test Your Thesis, Operate & Grow the Business
Our VerdictRead it for the diagnosis, not the prescription: it describes the business you are buying more accurately than the seller will.Read it on the far side of the close. It answers what to do with the cash a business makes, which is the question waiting once the search is over.
Pros
  • Names the single condition that decides whether a small business is worth buying: whether it runs without its owner
  • The systems-and-roles framing is the same one a buyer needs for the transition plan, so it reads as preparation rather than theory
  • Short, and old enough that the businesses on the market today were often built by people who read it
  • The clearest statement of the decision an owner makes over and over after the close, which is where the cash goes
  • Argues from one measure it names up front, the long-run return per share, so a reader can check the case instead of admiring it
  • Eight self-contained chapters, so it works read one CEO at a time during a search
Cons
  • Written for someone starting a business, not buying one: no diligence, no financing, no seller handoff
  • The parable format and the repetition test the patience of anyone who wanted a manual
  • Its examples predate the software a small company runs on now, so the tooling advice has aged where the argument has not
  • Every company in it is a public one far larger than anything a searcher buys, so the mechanics do not transfer and only the thinking does
  • Published in October 2012 and unrevised, so nothing in it touches how a small acquisition is financed or priced today

Our take

Read The E-Myth Revisited before you sign, because what it describes is the company you are about to buy: a business built by somebody good at the work rather than by somebody building a company, with the owner inside the job instead of above it. That is owner-dependence, which is the single condition deciding whether a small business is worth owning, and the documented-systems-and-defined-roles fix is the same frame a transition plan needs, so it reads as preparation rather than theory. It was written for someone starting a business, so there is no diligence, no financing and no seller handoff anywhere in it, and the parable format repeats itself enough to test anyone who wanted a manual.

Read The Outsiders after the close, when the recurring decision is where the cash goes. It measures eight chief executives on one thing it names up front, the long-run return per share, and finds that what they shared was capital allocation, including buying back their own shares when nothing better was on offer. Eight self-contained chapters mean it works read one at a time while a search is still running. Every company in it is a public one far larger than anything a searcher buys, so the mechanics do not transfer and only the thinking does, and it has been unrevised since 2012, which is why nothing in it touches how a small acquisition is financed or priced today.